U.S. Companies In China Get Caught In The Trade War Crossfire

Aug 27, 2019
Originally published on August 27, 2019 3:56 pm

When President Trump announced a new round of tariffs on Chinese imports last week, he made clear he was ready to sever ties between the United States and China, if necessary, to win the trade war.

"We don't need China," the president tweeted, "and, frankly, would be far better off without them."

But a growing number of American companies need China very much and stand to lose if the trade war lasts too long.

U.S. firms such as Starbucks, Nike and Boeing now make a large part of their profits serving the vast and growing Chinese middle class.

"China has become the largest market to sell into for many of America's largest companies," says Shaun Rein, managing director of the China Market Research Group, which advises U.S. companies doing business in China.

The growing importance of China's consumer market is often overlooked in U.S. political debate, which tends to focus on the huge number of jobs lost as U.S. companies have shifted overseas in search of low-wage labor, says Patrick Chovanec, chief strategist at Silvercrest Asset Management, who taught in China for years.

"I think that's one of the things that's often forgotten when we talk about the trade war, because usually it's framed in terms of outsourcing, which, yes, does exist. But there's this whole business of being in China in order to be in China," Chovanec says.

Consider this:

  • KFC now sells more chicken in China than in the United States. "Wherever you go in China, there's KFC, there's Starbucks, there's McDonald's," says Chovanec.
  • Together with its Chinese partners, General Motors sold 3.6 million vehicles in China last year, more than in the United States. GM brands, such as Cadillac, and Boeing remain very popular in China.
  • More than a third of the engines made by Indiana-based Cummins were sold in China last year. "We have a number of manufacturing facilities there and approximately 90% to 95% of the products that we make in China are sold in the China market," says Cummins spokesman Jon Mills. Revenue made in China helps pay for research and development and can offset losses during bad times in the U.S., he says.

To be sure, American companies still face plenty of barriers in China. Industries such as banking remain closed to outsiders, and many American companies that want to operate in China are still forced into joint ventures with Chinese partners. Intellectual property theft remains a big problem.

But China's middle class is now bigger than the entire U.S. population, and opportunities to make money abound there, says Anna Ashton, senior director of government affairs at the US-China Business Council.

"The vast majority of our companies have consistently reported and continue to report every year that their China operations are profitable — and not just profitable but more profitable than their operations overall," she says.

"The market in China — I am so bullish on it for the long term," Starbucks CEO Kevin Johnson told Bloomberg last month. "We're going to be able to accelerate and build new stores for a long, long time in China."

But the ongoing trade war tosses a new element of uncertainty into the best-laid plans of CEOs.

China has shown in the past that it will retaliate against companies it is displeased with.

After Marriott referred to Taiwan as a separate country on its website, the Beijing government shut down its online reservation site in China for a week, Rein says. More recently, the Chinese government took aim at Hong Kong companies such as airline Cathay Pacific because of the political turmoil there.

The government could easily make life difficult for American companies, by slowing down the permitting process for new stores or imposing stiff fines for minor infractions, for example.

It could even encourage consumers to boycott companies to punish their home countries. After South Korea installed a U.S.-made anti-missile system, Beijing ordered travel agencies to stop sending group tours there, which hurt tourism in South Korea.

China hasn't done anything like that to American companies so far, in part because it sees U.S. business leaders — many of whom have criticized Trump's trade policies — as allies, Rein says.

But if trade tensions get bad enough, Beijing won't hesitate to take aim at U.S. businesses, hurting U.S. stock prices and perhaps forcing Trump to reconsider the trade war, Chovanec says.

If that happens, some companies could end up as casualties. Trump has shown little concern for the vagaries suffered by U.S. companies in China, Chovanec says.

"U.S. companies in China doing business ... to serve the Chinese market have basically been orphaned by this trade war," he says.

Copyright 2019 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

AILSA CHANG, HOST:

Last week, President Trump announced he was raising tariffs on more Chinese imports. At the time, he put out a tweet saying, we don't need China and, frankly, would be better off without them. But a growing number of American companies need China very much. They now make a sizable part of their profits there. NPR's Jim Zarroli reports.

JIM ZARROLI, BYLINE: When American politicians talk about China's economy, they usually talk about lost factory jobs. A huge number of U.S. companies have fled to China over the years in search of low-wage labor. But Shaun Rein of the China Market Research Group in Shanghai says that's only part of the story. As China's middle class has grown, he says...

SHAUN REIN: China has become the largest market to sell into for many of America's largest companies, like Starbucks, like Nike.

ZARROLI: One in 4 of the airplanes made by Boeing last year went to China. KFC sells more chicken in China than in the U.S. And General Motors and its partners sold nearly 4 million vehicles in China last year.

(SOUNDBITE OF CADILLAC AD)

UNIDENTIFIED ACTOR #1: (Speaking Chinese).

UNIDENTIFIED ACTOR #2: Cadillac.

ZARROLI: Increasingly, companies that hope to grow can't afford to overlook the Chinese market. China now buys more than a third of the engines sold by the Indiana-based company Cummins, says company spokesman Jon Mills.

JON MILLS: We have a number of manufacturing facilities there. And approximately 90- to 95% of the products that we make in China are sold in the China market.

ZARROLI: American companies still face plenty of barriers in China. Industries such as banking remain closed to outsiders. Intellectual property theft is a problem, and many American companies are still forced into joint ventures with Chinese partners. But China's middle class is now bigger than the entire U.S. population. And there are plenty of opportunities there, says Anna Ashton of the US-China Business Council.

ANNA ASHTON: The vast majority of our companies have consistently reported and continue to report every year that their China operations were profitable - and not just profitable but more profitable than their operations overall.

ZARROLI: And companies see a very bright future in China. Here's Starbucks CEO Kevin Johnson in an interview on Bloomberg TV last month.

(SOUNDBITE OF BLOOMBERG TV BROADCAST)

KEVIN JOHNSON: We're going to be able to accelerate and build new stores for a long, long time in China.

ZARROLI: But the trade war threatens to upend the plans companies have made. Shaun Rein of the China Market Research Group says the Chinese government has shown it's willing to punish companies when it's unhappy. Last year, he says, Marriott ticked off the government when it listed Taiwan as a separate country on its website.

REIN: So as a punishment, China actually blocked the marriott.cn website for one week in China, so nobody was able to book any hotel rooms.

ZARROLI: The government can get back at American companies by, say, slowing down the permitting process for new stores or encouraging consumers to boycott U.S. brands. Rein says the Chinese government hasn't done this in part because it sees American companies as allies. Many U.S. business leaders have criticized Trump's trade policies.

But Patrick Chovanec of Silvercrest Asset Management says U.S. companies remain in a difficult position.

PATRICK CHOVANEC: U.S. companies in China - doing business in China to serve the Chinese market have been basically orphaned by this trade war.

ZARROLI: For the Trump administration, he says, the trade war is about bringing American jobs back home. But if tensions get bad enough, he says, China won't hesitate to retaliate against American companies.

Jim Zarroli, NPR News, New York. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.