Puerto Ricans Concerned That $20 Billion Recovery Plan Is 'Not For The People'

Jan 28, 2019
Originally published on January 29, 2019 7:51 am

César Díaz felt lucky that only a couple of leaks had sprung in his ceiling, even though Hurricane Maria tore the zinc panels off much of his roof. His real troubles began about a year after the storm, when a crew hired by Puerto Rico's housing department showed up to make the repairs.

"They weren't very professional," Díaz said. "They didn't wear gloves, and they asked if I had an extra piece of wood."

Within days, there were new leaks. Not only in the living room but in the bedroom, over his daughter's crib.

"None of those were there before," he said, pointing to a half-dozen brown splotches in the ceiling. Díaz, a music teacher and member of the town council in the hard-hit municipality of Loiza, knew that many of his neighbors were still waiting for repairs. So he began teaching himself the basics of construction.

"Puerto Rico has always been in the path of hurricanes, and it always will be. So in my opinion, a good roof is a matter of life or death," he said. "I want to be able to tell if the crews the government is sending to repair houses in my community are doing the work right."

Díaz is not alone in his scrutiny as Puerto Rico's government ushers in the next phase of its reconstruction — a massive rebuilding effort funded by nearly $20 billion in grants from the federal Department of Housing and Urban Development. Island officials will have broad discretion to spend the money as they see fit — from repairing damaged homes and building new ones, to shoring up crumbled roads and infrastructure, to launching tourism and business development projects.

But the pressure to spend the money wisely and efficiently is enormous, not least because President Trump himself has reportedly tried to hold up various sources of funding for the island after accusing its elected officials of being "inept politicians" likely to mismanage the funds.

Many Puerto Ricans have denounced those attacks as unfair stereotypes. Even so, people on the island have their own concerns about the government's plans for the money, given its poor response in the immediate aftermath of the hurricane, the lack of transparency in many agencies, and the persistent perception that cronyism rules when it comes to government contracting. The island's governor, Ricardo Rosselló, seems well aware of these concerns, and said he's gone so far as to ask officials at HUD to hold his government accountable for its spending.

A gas station remains damaged in Loiza.
Erika P. Rodríguez for NPR

"We have an opportunity we haven't had in two or three generations," Rosselló said during recent public remarks, "and that we may never have again if we don't make the most of it."

Officials on the island see the $20 billion HUD allocation as an historic opportunity to fund public projects that the bankrupt territory could never otherwise afford. Massive budget cuts and austerity measures imposed by a federal oversight board working to dig the island out of $73 billion of debt have sliced deeply into the government's ability to provide basic services.

So the HUD grants are a rare bright spot. Over the last year, the government has developed a series of broad spending plans that are in various stages of approval by the federal agency. And though disbursements were held up by the federal government shutdown, officials expect the first several hundred million dollars to begin flowing imminently.

A plan "not for the people"

But on an island where damage from Hurricane Maria is still visible on nearly every city block and around every bend in Puerto Rico's many winding rural roads, some on the island are questioning whether the government is fully prepared to get the money where it needs to go. They worry that in the rush to get the money flowing, many communities may be overlooked.

"This money could be the answer for many communities that within an austerity crisis would not see any money coming in," said Ariadna Godreau-Aubert, executive director of Ayuda Legal Puerto Rico, a nonprofit that has been urging the government to seek more public participation as it has developed its spending plans. "But what we've seen so far is that this is a plan for developers, and not for the people."

The island's government has rushed through public comment periods and not made a meaningful public outreach effort, Godreau-Aubert said. The process for proposing projects for funding is highly technical and can require large lines of credit often accessible to developers but not to groups working in local communities. And the government has only posted contract bidding documents in English on an island where just 20 percent of residents report speaking the language well.

"What happens is that when people are not part of the process, they become displaced by the process," Godreau-Aubert said. Officials will use a significant chunk of the first $1.5 billion that HUD has approved to relocate families whose homes are in flood-prone or other risky areas. To advocates like Godreau-Aubert and others, that sounds like tearing communities apart.

Asked about these concerns, Gov. Rosselló said they were overblown.

A long-abandoned water filtration plant in Camuy. Now that it appears money from HUD may arrive before some FEMA funds, Mayor Edwin García Feliciano's staff has been working feverishly to complete the list of projects he wants the island's government to approve for funding.
Erika P. Rodríguez for NPR

"I'm telling you this from the bottom of my heart. We want this plan of reconstruction not to be the governor's plan or the mayors' plan. It needs to be the plan of all Puerto Ricans," Rosselló said.

Public outreach is a HUD requirement, and the governor said his government has taken it seriously.

"But make no mistake about it, we're moving fast, but we're moving transparently and collaboratively so we can have the best long-term reconstruction of Puerto Rico," the governor said.

Pressing for more flexibility

Still, the calls on the governor to slow things down and engage more broadly with the island's civil society are growing. In large part that's because, like the governor, others view the avalanche of federal funds as Puerto Rico's one shot to make a meaningful dent in some of the island's most entrenched social problems, especially housing.

On Thursday, researchers at The Center for a New Economy, a respected San Juan think tank, warned that while the government's spending plans for the HUD grants do a good job of identifying many of the problems facing Puerto Rico's housing stock – like informality, the lack of affordability, and widespread damage from the storm – the plans do not outline a nuanced or comprehensive path forward.

An long-abandoned water filtration plant and a tree with an attached sign labeling it as dangerous. Though dead, the tree stands precariously beside utility cables and a house in Camuy.
Erika P. Rodríguez for NPR

"What you see is that the government has a menu of proposals, but it's not clear how they're interconnected," said Raúl Santiago-Bartolomei, the center's expert on federal recovery funding on the island.

Starting next month, the center will launch a series of conferences aimed at bringing longtime social advocates, researchers and planners together with government officials. Deepak Lamba-Nieves, the center's research director, said doing so is necessary in part because budget cuts have gutted some of the government agencies that might otherwise be equipped to thoughtfully plan the island's reconstruction.

It is a gargantuan challenge given the often competing pressures on the central government from the island's 78 mayors, private developers, and large nonprofits — all wanting their share of the federal windfall.

Edwin García Feliciano, mayor of the northwestern town of Camuy, is frustrated by how long it's taken FEMA to fund important repairs in his community.
Erika P. Rodríguez for NPR

In the northwestern municipality of Camuy, Mayor Edwin García Feliciano said that after the hurricane, he was frustrated by how long it took FEMA to fund important repairs in his community. In some cases, he is still waiting.

Now that it appears money from HUD may arrive first, his staff has been working feverishly to come up with the list of projects he intends to submit to the island's central government for funding: roof repairs for hundreds of families in his city still living under blue tarps, new pumping facilities that would provide more reliable running water, and road improvements, among others.

"I've been mayor for more than 16 years, and I've never had this kind of opportunity to improve Camuy," García said. He and other mayors, including Carmen Yulín Cruz, of San Juan, are also arguing for greater flexibility in how they spend HUD funds in their own communities, arguing that'll make the recovery more nimble.

But García said the central government may do a city-by-city assessment before deciding whether to grant such flexibility. In some towns, he said, there are concerns about fiscal health, staffing levels, and corruption.

"Unlike some mayors, I have never been investigated for misuse of public funds," García said, "so I see no reason why I shouldn't have that flexibility."

While mayors are likely to be the principal conduit for federal money into communities, they aren't the only ones drawing up their lists of projects.

When Porfidio Román learned close to a year ago that the island's housing department was hosting a public hearing to take suggestions on how it should spend the billions in federal grants, he drew up his own list.

Román served on the Camuy city council more than a decade ago, and is now a private citizen. He still walks the neighborhoods frequently and knows many of Camuy's problems, down to the spots where the sidewalk ends. He has politicking in his blood, and said he has designs on running for mayor when García retires.

On a recent morning, Román drove his bright orange pickup truck along Camuy's winding mountain roads and pointed to several of the projects he'd included on the list he submitted at the public hearing. There was the stretch of road where he said a few more utility posts would connect an adjacent neighborhood to a more reliable section of the electric grid than the one that currently powers it. There was a long-abandoned water filtration plant that, if reopened, he said, could provide more consistent running water to two nearby barrios.

Then he stopped at a small sports arena. Hurricane Maria had smashed in the roof, and more than a year later, it was still a mangle of metal.

The Camuy town square.
Erika P. Rodríguez for NPR

"This barrio was left without any place for recreation," Román said, "and some families with children in sports have even moved away because of that. More than a year later we're still waiting for the money to fix it."

Román has no idea whether any of the billions in federal grants will find their way to the projects he's proposed. What he knows, he said, is that the answer will say a lot about how serious Puerto Rico's politicians are about ensuring the money for the island's reconstruction gets to the places that need it most.

Copyright 2019 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.


The federal government is getting ready to give Puerto Rico nearly $20 billion to help rebuild from Hurricane Maria. Local officials say it's enough money to transform the island and boost the economy there for years - if the money is well spent. Here's NPR's Adrian Florido.

ADRIAN FLORIDO, BYLINE: Puerto Rico's governor, Ricardo Rossello, got up in front of hundreds of people at the convention center in San Juan last month.


RICARDO ROSSELLO: (Speaking Spanish).


ROSSELLO: (Speaking Spanish).

FLORIDO: It was an event for people interested in getting jobs in construction because as federal money starts flowing to fund the next phase of the island's recovery from Maria, the government expects it will need 100,000 people to do all the work.


ROSSELLO: (Speaking Spanish).

FLORIDO: "We know we've been through difficult times," the governor said. "But now we're standing at the doorstep of Puerto Rico's reconstruction." The government expects to repair tens of thousands of homes and build many new ones, new bridges and roads, projects to promote tourism and the economy - all funded by $20 billion in disaster recovery grants from the federal housing department over the next several years.


ROSSELLO: (Speaking Spanish).

FLORIDO: We have an opportunity we haven't had in generations, the governor said. We have to make the most of it. Puerto Rico is mired in a 13-year-long recession. Its debt burden and budget cuts mean the island could never fund many of these projects on its own. But as they prepare to spend the money, officials also know they're facing a lot of scrutiny, especially from President Trump, who said he expects the island's, quote, "inept politicians" to mismanage the funds and has also tried to block some funding for Puerto Rico.

Many Puerto Ricans dismissed those attacks as unfair stereotypes. That doesn't mean, though, that there aren't people on the island with their own concerns about how the money is going to be spent. Ariadna Godreau-Aubert directs Ayuda Legal Puerto Rico, a nonprofit pressuring the government to more deeply engage with local communities as it develops its plans for the HUD grants.

ARIADNA GODREAU-AUBERT: This money could be the answer for many communities that, within an austerity crisis, will never see any kind of money coming in.

FLORIDO: But she says that in its rush to get the money flowing, the government has cut corners, not gotten enough public input.

GODREAU-AUBERT: When people is not part of the process, people are displaced by the process.

FLORIDO: The government plans to spend much of this money to relocate many thousands of people from flood-prone and risky areas to new homes elsewhere. To advocates like Godreau-Aubert, that sounds like tearing communities apart.

GODREAU-AUBERT: What we have seen so far is that this is a plan for developers and not a plan for the people.


ROSSELLO: I'm telling you this from the bottom of my heart. We want this plan of reconstruction not to be the governor's plan or not to be, you know, the mayor's plan. It needs to be the plan of all Puerto Ricans.

FLORIDO: That was Governor Rossello when I asked him about Godreau-Aubert's concerns at a recent press conference.


ROSSELLO: Make no mistake about it. We're moving fast, but we're moving transparently and collaboratively so that we can have the best long-term reconstruction of Puerto Rico.

FLORIDO: Cesar Diaz says if that long-term reconstruction looks like what happened at his house, he's worried.


FLORIDO: Diaz lives in the town of Loiza, on the island's north coast. He got his roof patched up under a program paid for by FEMA and run by Puerto Rico's housing department. But when the work crew showed up, they weren't very professional, he remembers. He says the first day it rained after they made the repairs, his roof leaked in places it hadn't before. He points to brown splotches on the ceiling.

CESAR DIAZ: (Speaking Spanish).

FLORIDO: "Here, there, over there," he says, "all those leaks are new." Diaz says that many of his neighbors who still have blue tarps over the roofs are hopeful that once the billions start to flow, the government will finally help repair their roofs. But Diaz worries that if the work's not done well, the next hurricane will blow the roofs off again.

DIAZ: (Speaking Spanish).

FLORIDO: "Puerto Rico has always been in the path of hurricanes, and it always will be," Diaz said. "So having a strong roof is a matter of life or death," Diaz says.

Adrian Florido, NPR News, Loiza, Puerto Rico.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARP'S "NZUKU") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.