With More Women In State Office, Family Leave Policies Have Not Caught Up

16 hours ago

A nameplate that reads "Mom Boss" sits on the desk of Michigan state Sen. Stephanie Chang's basement office in the capitol building in Lansing. Around it sit framed photos of her daughters.

When Chang began her term in the Michigan House in 2015, she was pregnant, and then again when she started her term in the Michigan Senate in 2018. In her official role, she's the Minority Floor Leader for the Democrats. Unofficially, she's branded herself a #mommylegislator.

Before this year, Chang was the only woman in the 184-year history of the Michigan State Senate to give birth during her term.

"I know it sounds crazy, but we did actually try to time it to have her during the summer recess because we knew that the legislative work would be lighter at that time," says Chang talking about the birth of her first daughter.

After her first baby, Chang took five weeks off. She says it's been a challenge balancing motherhood and her job as a legislator, but she's felt mostly supported by her constituents and colleagues in the legislature.

Seven weeks ago, state Sen. Mallory McMorrow became the second woman to give birth while serving in the state Senate.

Like many parents, McMorrow planned to take time off with her new daughter Noa, but she was surprised to find that she didn't qualify for the 12 weeks of paid time off that the more than 49,000 Michigan state employees began receiving in 2020.

Because McMorrow isn't an employee of the state of Michigan – rather an elected official whose pay is written into the state constitution — she doesn't qualify for parental leave. In Michigan, there is no actual parental leave policy for state legislators.

Lawmakers, technically speaking, can take as much or as little time off as they want. The catch: They miss votes, both in committee and on the floor and Michigan is one of about 20% of states that serves on a full-time basis. Aside from a short summer recess, lawmakers work the entire year.

McMorrow, who became a lawmaker after time in the auto and advertising industries, says the lack of a leave policy in the legislature is archaic, even in comparison to the male-dominated industries she came from.

"The rules of the institution, that people hear about all the time, are arbitrary. And they are clearly set up by men who don't have those shared responsibilities," says McMorrow. "It's either been their wives who have stayed home with kids, or their grandkids, and they just haven't had to think about it."

McMorrow says under the current conditions in the legislature, she doesn't feel supported as a working mom.

"I can't vote remotely. I can't proxy vote. I have to physically go to Lansing. And I have a newborn who naps for 20 minutes, and then is up again and ready to eat and be changed."

I can't vote remotely. I can't proxy vote. I have to physically go to Lansing. And I have a newborn who naps for 20 minutes, and then is up again and ready to eat and be changed. - Michigan State Sen. Mallory McMorrow, a Democrat

She says it's a version of the conversation she's had with women executives and friends that "women can have it all, but not all at once."

Options for remote participation need to be instituted, McMorrow says, or at the very least, a leave policy needs to be codified.

"Are we comfortable with the idea that we don't want working moms in the legislature? Because that's the message unless we change the system," she says.

It's not just Michigan. There's no set policy for parental leave in place or mechanism to participate in committees or session remotely for full-time lawmakers in Ohio. And while there are temporary provisions for remote participation in Pennsylvania this year — there isn't a policy in place there either.

These conversations about parental leave policies are new, according to Jean Sinzdak, the Associate Director of the Center for American Women and Politics at Rutgers University. One of the reasons: Three-quarters of all elected officials are still men.

In Michigan, according to CAWP, women make up nearly 36% of the state legislature. Historically, women have waited until after children are grown to run for office because of constraints like childcare.

"When you do not have policies in place that level the playing field and make it easier for people to participate, it naturally continues the institutionalization of the barriers ... that people just can't get over those hurdles," says Sinzdak.

But she says things are changing. Concerns about parental leave policies are being raised for the first time in many places after wave elections in 2018 and 2020 when women like McMorrow and Chang were elected.

Women in state legislatures are no longer subject to superlatives like the "first" or "the only."

"Now we're getting to a point where [there's] a little bit more of a groundswell among the women who were serving, but also younger women who were just not willing to put up with it as it is. They're willing to disrupt, and to ask those questions [and] say, 'Wait a minute, why do we do it this way? Can we think of alternatives? How come we can't get parental leave?' or whatever the issue is," says Sinzdak.

McMorrow says she plans to introduce legislation to facilitate remote participation for instances where lawmakers may need to be absent like maternity leave, caretaking, or obligations as active-duty military.

Whether that's by remote or proxy voting, she's not sure yet. For now, she's taking the remainder of her 12 weeks to be with Noa, whether it's official or not.

Copyright 2021 WKAR Public Media. To see more, visit WKAR Public Media.

SARAH MCCAMMON, HOST:

More women than ever are serving as state lawmakers across the country. But in most capitals, family leave policies have not changed. That leaves new moms with few options when having children. Abigail Censky has more from member station WKAR in Lansing.

ABIGAIL CENSKY, BYLINE: Mallory McMorrow was part of 2018's so-called Year Of The Woman, when a record number of women were elected to office. She flipped a Michigan state Senate district in the suburbs of Detroit.

MALLORY MCMORROW: Your first interview - and you're very hungry.

CENSKY: Seven weeks ago, she gave birth to her first daughter, Noa.

MCMORROW: This is Noa. She's like the size of the microphone. We know.

CENSKY: Like many parents, McMorrow is taking time off to be with her newborn. But while state employees get 12 weeks of paid time off, there's no parental leave policy for lawmakers. They answer to their constituents. And their pay is written in the state constitution. So they can technically take off as much time as they want, the catch being they missed votes.

MCMORROW: I can't vote remotely. I can't proxy vote. I have to physically go to Lansing. And I have a newborn who naps for 20 minutes and then is up again and ready to eat and be changed.

CENSKY: Michigan is one of a handful of legislatures where lawmakers work full time. Senator McMorrow said she spoke up because she could already envision attack ads criticizing her for not being in the Capitol to vote - votes she missed, so she could spend time with her baby.

MCMORROW: Are we comfortable with the idea that we don't want working moms in the legislature? Because that's the message unless we change the system.

CENSKY: She says this is a conversation she's had with many women, that women can have it all, just not all at once. And that feels true for her in the legislature.

MCMORROW: The rules of the institution are arbitrary. And they are clearly set up by men who don't have those shared responsibilities. And it's been their wives who have stayed home with kids or their grandkids.

CENSKY: McMorrow and state Senator Stephanie Chang are the only two women who have ever given birth during their tenure in the Michigan Senate. Inside of her Capitol office with pictures of her kids and a sign that says mom boss on her desk, Chang says she planned to have her first daughter at a very specific time of year.

STEPHANIE CHANG: I had her actually sort of intentionally. Like, I know it sounds crazy. But we actually did try to time it to have her during the summer recess because we knew that the legislative work would be lighter at that time.

CENSKY: Chang took five weeks after having her baby and says it's challenging. But she's felt mostly supported during her time as what she calls a mommy legislator. Jean Sinzdak is the associate director of the Center for American Women and Politics at Rutgers University. She says conversations about parental leave are brand-new because three quarters of all elected officials are still men. And women have historically run after they had children.

JEAN SINZDAK: This is, like, the first time in the last few years we feel like there's been real movement in any kind of way. And it's not coincidental.

CENSKY: Sinzdak points to wave elections in 2018 and 2020, when women like McMorrow were elected. They're part of a group of younger women who are challenging the status quo.

SINZDAK: We're nowhere near parity. But we're a lot closer than we have been. And when you talk about one of these women raising this issue, it would not have gotten raised probably if she wasn't there.

CENSKY: Back in the suburbs of Detroit, McMorrow says after she returns from maternity leave, she'll introduce legislation to allow remote or proxy voting. But for now, she's spending time with her daughter. For NPR News, I'm Abigail Censky in Lansing. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.