Proton beam therapy is among the most expensive cancer treatments, but there’s little evidence that it’s any better than conventional radiation dosages and some private insurers are starting to tell physicians they’ll no longer pay for it.
Still, proton beam facilities are popping up across the country. The latest on the books in Dallas is estimated to cost $270 million. Even small cities want a piece of the proton therapy business.
Construction is underway on one in Shreveport, Louisiana. It’s one of at least 15 proton therapy centers rising up around the country.
Dr. Lane Rosen, director of radiation oncology at Willis-Knighton Health System, says patients are demanding proton beam therapy. Currently, they have to make a five-hour drive to Houston for the nearest facility.
“This is not something that the average radiation oncology department can afford to do,” Rosen says.
Rosen thinks the proton therapy that will be offered at Shreveport’s $40 million facility will be the future of cancer treatment.
“Even if you’re not willing to accept an improvement in cure, the reduction in side effects is absolute and undebated,” Rosen says.
The research is far from complete, according to Dr. Joel Tepper, a radiation oncology professor at the University of North Carolina. But that hasn’t curbed enthusiasm.
“It’s very good for marketing. You can say we have the latest and the greatest,” Tepper says.
Tepper contends the financial model here is built on volume: building a center that costs a lot of money but packing in a lot of patients.
“There’s a large burden on the health care system in the country to pay more money for a procedure that is no better,” Tepper says.
But private health insurers may not foot the bill for long. At least three major providers recently stopped covering the procedure in early stages of prostate cancer. That hasn’t deterred proton center construction. Amitabh Chandra, a professor of public policy at Harvard University and a critic of proton beam therapy, says that’s because these facilities take years for investors to secure tens of millions of dollars.
“Now the world has changed, and so, the people who bet on proton beam are likely to be very upset with the fact that it’s not going to be reimbursed by private insurers,” Chandra says.
But Dr. Lane Rosen is focused on the day he can zap cancer cells with proton beams. His unit will be ready for patients a year from now.
There's always plenty of gadget and software news out there, but not many people look directly at the larger question -- is technology making us better, or worse? Clive Thompson, New York Times, Wired Magazine contributor and author of Smarter Than You Think: How Technology Is Changing Our Minds for The Better, joins Marketplace Tech host Ben Johnson to discuss.
Click on the audio player above to hear the full interview.
The lawsuit takes aim at provisions that limit early voting periods and require government photo ID as an illegal form of discrimination against minorities at the ballot box, according to a person briefed on the Justice Department's plans.
Wilson Kipsang of Kenya set a new world record time in the marathon of 2 hours 3 minutes 23 seconds at the Berlin Marathon.
The Yarnell Hill fire in Arizona was deadly in part because of the how close a highly flammable forest was to a community. The U.S. once faced a crisis with structural fires, but managed to change regulations to turn the trend around. Experts say it will take a renewed effort to take on this newer fire threat.
The Brandon Training School housed people with developmental disabilities from 1915 to 1993. A commemoration this month of former residents is emblematic of a larger national movement to honor and mark the graves of people who lived and died as wards of the state.
Some stories from the isolated nation are stranger than government-sponsored fiction. AP Asia correspondent Tim Sullivan brings us unexpected tales, like the North Korean love affair with Gone with the Wind.
Kenyan authorities say they've made another arrest in the deadly attack on an upscale mall that shocked Nairobi last week. But officials are also facing questions over reports of intelligence that may have given warnings about the attack, which ended with at least 67 deaths.
Hundreds of cars that were stockpiled by a Chevrolet dealer in Nebraska are finally being sold — many for the first time. The Lambrecht Chevrolet collection stretches back to the 1950s and has drawn bids and interest from around the world.
The attack occurred as many students of an agricultural college slept. As many as 50 people may be dead as a result of violence that is being blamed on the group Boko Haram.
Suspected Islamic extremists attacked an agricultural college in the dead of night, gunning down dozens of students as they slept in dormitories and torching classrooms, the school's provost said of an ongoing northeastern Nigeria's ongoing Islamic uprising.
Sheikh Saleh al-Luhaydan warned women against driving cars by saying it could affect their ovaries. His comments come a month before a planned day of disobedience, when activists will call for women to drive — a right they do not have in Saudi Arabia.
An explosion has killed at least 37 people in Peshawar, Pakistan, where authorities say they suspect a car bomb was detonated in a street market near a police station. The powerful blast left a scene of devastation, with casualties and severe damage to nearby buildings.
The federal government has moved closer to the brink of a shutdown, as the House of Representatives approved a temporary funding bill Saturday night that the Senate and White House say has no chance of becoming law. Here's what the legislators are saying.
Social practices train us to see and experience race in certain ways, regardless of whether we are sighted or not, according to a professor from the University of California, Hastings College of the Law.
Protesters are dressing up as superheroes to demonstrate in Rio de Janeiro, but that's not the only place caped crusaders have taken to Latin American streets.
The House voted to tie government funding to a one-year delay of Obamacare early Sunday morning. The measure is a non-starter in the Senate and the president vows to veto, making a government shutdown all the more likely.
On Tuesday, a key part of the Affordable Care Act is going live: People will be able to buy health insurance from new marketplaces in every state. Researchers and wonks will be intensely interested. Most of the rest of us will be clueless.
The new federal health law has a few exemptions from its insurance mandate, including health care sharing ministries. Members pay a monthly fee to help cover some of each other's medical costs — but there are no guarantees.
The National Security Agency's effort to find connections between suspects has led the agency to collate reams of phone and e-mail data with information from sources that include GPS data and Facebook, according to The New York Times. The newspaper cites documents provided by former NSA contract worker Edward Snowden.